‘Black aspiration and white fear causing tension in South Africa’

Much patience is needed for South Africa to develop social cohesion, black church leader Reverend Frank Chikane said in Kliptown, Soweto on Thursday.

“We need to be ready to listen to each other,” he said during a report back from commissions at the national social cohesion summit.

“To build social cohesion and a common nation, a national identity is needed.”

Chikane, former director general in the presidency, was reporting back on the commission which dealt with prejudice and discrimination.

He said it was a difficult commission. High levels of sensitivity and humility were needed.

“We need to listen to each other… We must also listen when people speak in strange tongues.”

The two-day summit, organised by the department of arts and culture, broke up into five commissions on Thursday. Language was a recurring theme in each commission.

Wits University Professor Yunus Ballim, reporting back from the commission on economic inequalities, said South Africa needed to develop a shared discourse.

“Just to have the ability to greet each other in an African language or say goodbye in an African language.”

It was embarrassing that many people could not do that after 18-years of democracy.

Social historian Luli Callinicos said minority groups had done very little to try learn an African language.

“Our own culture is being undermined… We need to restore ubuntu,” she said. “Because this is something we can teach the rest of the world. We must be careful not to lose it.”

Callinicos was part of the commission on social interaction, co-operation and solidarity. Poverty and inequality added to the lack of social cohesion.

“Cohesion, if you are deprived, is going to be very difficult,” she said.

People in most of the commissions also called for a public dialogue and said the development of social cohesion started at a local level and needed to be ongoing.

Former ambassador to France and jazz legend Hugh Masekela’s sister Barbara Masekela said the relevance of the Constitution should not be set aside only for when needed but should be used in people’s daily lives.

This was part of the commission on national identity and unity.

Chikane said delegates questioned the Constitution.

“There were questions about the foundation of our new society in terms of the Constitution,” he said.

He said there were good structures and institutions but they were not doing enough to develop social cohesion.

Another commission on special divisions focused on the issue of land.

Leonard Martin, who reported back, said there was an urgent need for a land audit because of the persistent problem of “landlessness”.

He said land had caused great tension in South Africa. There was “black aspiration and white fear”.

He said the commission urged people to build a unified country.

“Build a South Africa that belongs to all.”

Martin said there needed to be robust and honest discussions about South Africa’s past. – Sapa

White minority still feels racially superior – ANC minister

If South Africa is to achieve social cohesion some people cannot continue feeling superior to others, Home Affairs Minister Nkosazana Dlamini-Zuma said on Wednesday.

“It is very divisive when a minority wants to be treated separately to the majority,” she told the national social cohesion summit in Soweto, Johannesburg.

For real social cohesion, equality must be understood and practised, she said.

“It doesn’t augur well if there are people who still feel superior to others… There are people who still feel superior by the mere fact that they belong to a different race.”

Earlier, Freedom Front Plus MP Corne Mulder called for a ministry for minority affairs.

Dlamini-Zuma called for increased state participation.

“The state must not be a passive state… because you can’t transform with a state that is standing by and leaving everything to uncertain markets. Markets cannot transform society.”

The summit was being held in Kliptown, where 3000 delegates of all races met in 1955 to draft the Freedom Charter, which calls for a non-racial South Africa that belongs to all who live in it.

Delegates explored the role of the judiciary, Parliament, political parties and traditional leaders, among others, in building an inclusive society.

Justice Minister Jeff Radebe said independence of the judiciary was guaranteed by the Constitution.

“As a government we have no intention of interfering with its independence.”

He said the establishment of an Office of the Chief Justice was the first step towards the total independence of the judiciary.

Arts and Culture Minister Paul Mashatile, whose department was hosting the two-day event, said the summit would not be a mere talk shop.

“Out of it must come decisive steps,” he said. These included a clear plan of action to heal the wounds of the past and strengthen social cohesion.

Political parties, business leaders, and civil society and government representatives attended the summit.

Among them were National Assembly Speaker Max Sisulu, former Speaker Frene Ginwala, and Zanele Mbeki, wife of former president Thabo Mbeki.

The summit’s theme is: “Working together to create a proud and caring society”.

President Jacob Zuma first called for such a summit in 2009. – Sapa